I really liked the Pirate Popsicle Collection.
It was simple and fun. It was much easier than others because we only needed to finish one row to get the Puffin. The desert shop was a good choice as it has items that are cheap and quick to make.
It would have been nice if after earning our puffin, if we could have finished the other rows for some smaller prizes. A pirate beehive would have been adorable, a pirate orange tree (don't want our pirate farmers getting scurvy!) and some other silly themed item to finish it off.
You guys are doing a great job of keeping this game fun and challenging ! Keep up the good work